Recordings

The recordings of Superme Judicial Court arguments are available shortly after the day of argument.

To watch a recording, click on the case name to be brought to the video on the Court's YouTube channel.

 

Oral Arguments October 8-10, 2024

Oral Arguments September 10-12, 2024
at the Cumberland County Courthouse in Portland

Judicial Discipline Matter
at the Cumberland County Courthouse in Portland

Oral Arguments June 5-6, 2024
at the Cumberland County Courthouse in Portland

Oral Arguments May 7-9, 2024
at the Cumberland County Courthouse in Portland

Oral Arguments: Wednesday, April 10, 2024
at the Capital Judicial Center, Augusta

Time Docket Number Case Name Attorneys Topics & Briefs
10:40 a.m. Oxf-23-366 Delanna Garey v. Stanford Management, LLC, et al. Christopher S. Berryment; Jeffrey D. Russell; Emily C. Waddell Defamation; exclusion from property

Appellant's brief
Appellees' brief

10:40 a.m. And-23-310 Helen Crabtree v. Central Maine Medical Center John P. Gause; Brooke K. Haley; Harper A. Weissburg; Peter G. Callaghan Employment discrimination; remedies



11:30 a.m. Cum-23-4 Ernest B. Weidul v. State of Maine Donald S. Hornblower; Donald W. Macomber Post-conviction review; effective assistance of counsel; change of post-conviction judicial officer

Appellant's brief
Appellee's brief

1:30 p.m. Ken-23-348 Eastern Maine Conservation Initiative et al. v. Board of Environmental Protection et al. Elizabeth A. Boepple; Sean R. Turley; Ellen P. Masalsky; Patrick I. Marass; Katherine A. Joyce; Rachael McEntee; Robert I. Martin; Jack Dafoe Natural Resources Protection Act; discharge of wastewater from aquaculture facility; independent review of impact on water quality; economic considerations

Appellants' brief
Appellee Kingfish Maine's brief
Appellee BEP's brief
Appellants' reply brief
2:20 p.m. Cum-23-329 Mark Cardilli Jr. v. State of Maine Thomas F. Hallett; Leanne Robbin Post-conviction review; manslaughter; expert testimony regarding use of force; ineffective assistance of counsel



3:10 p.m. Som-22-182 State of Maine v. Nicholas W. Norris Jason Horn; James M. Mason Dismissal of charge by State; speedy trial; probable cause to support search and tracking warrants





Oral Arguments: Thursday, April 11, 2024
At the Capital Judicial Center, Augusta

Time Docket Number Case Name Attorneys Topics & Briefs
9:50 a.m. WCB-23-313 Steve L. Michaud v. Caribou Ford Mercury, Inc., et al. Norman G. Trask; John J. Cronan III Workers' compensation; interest on specific-loss benefits

Appellant's brief
Appellees' brief
Appellees' reply brief

10:40 a.m. Som-23-261 State of Maine v. Dalvin Peguero Jason Horn; James M. Mason Aggravated trafficking of scheduled drugs; admissibility of testimony; scope of law enforcement search under warrant; sufficiency of jury deliberation time; sufficiency of evidence

Appellant's brief
Appellee's brief
Appellant's reply brief

11:30 a.m. Pen-23-357 State of Maine v. Corydon Judkins Mark A. Rucci; Joanne Lewis; Michelle R. King Domestic violence assault; hearsay; right to confront witness; right to counsel; denial of counsel's request to withdraw

Appellant's brief
Appellee's brief
Appellant's reply brief

1:30 p.m. Som-23-328 State of Maine v. Garrett J. Cote Jr. Maeghan Maloney; Francis Griffin Jr.; Erik T. Crocker Criminal threatening with a dangerous weapon; remedy for improper testimony or prior criminal record; self-defense

Appellant's brief
Appellee's brief

2:20 p.m. Cum-23-47 John R. Luongo v. Michael A. Luongo John S. Campbell; Roy T. Pierce Distribution of decedent's property; conversion; expenses



3:10 p.m. Som-22-182 State of Maine v. Nicholas W. Norris Jason Horn; James M. Mason Topics and summary to be announced