Skip Maine state header navigation

Agencies | Online Services | Help

Skip First Level Navigation | Skip All Navigation

Home > Opinions & Orders > Supreme Court Opinions

Supreme Court: Most Recent Opinions 

Most Recent Opinions

NOTE: Effective October 20, 2006, Maine Supreme Court opinions will be loaded on the web page in PDF format only. The html version will no longer be available.

NOTE: Effective October 31, 2006. In order to provide greater predictability in the publication of Law Court opinions, and to make it easier for the public to know when to look for opinions, the Supreme Judicial Court will publish opinions two days per week, beginning October 31, 2006. Opinions will be published at 11:00 a.m. on Tuesdays and Thursdays in pdf format. (Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader)

(If you want to "Watch This Page" on the Maine.gov customized page -- follow directions to receive e-mail notifications whenever this page is updated.)

Introduction

The opinions of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court sitting as the Law Court have been published on this site since January 1, 1997. Although opinions posted on this site are public documents and may be utilized and cited in this form, they are subject to revision and correction. When a revision or correction is made, the new version of that opinion will be posted on this site. The date of revision or correction as well as the date of initial publication will be indicated. Readers are asked to notify the Reporter of Decisions of any typographical, grammatical or formal errors by U.S. Mail to: Judicial Branch, Page Administrator, P O Box 368, Portland, ME 04112-0368, or by sending an email message to the page administrator.

Historical Note

The permanent official version of the Maine Supreme Judicial Court's opinions is that published in Atlantic Reporter, 2d Series, which has been Maine's Official Reporter since 1966. Cases published since January 1, 1997, should be cited in the following style:

Dutil v. Burns , 1997 ME 1,¶ 2, 687 A.2d 639, 640.

More information regarding the publication and citation of this Court's opinions.

Directions

To read an opinion online, select the name of the case. These opinions must be downloaded as Adobe Acrobat PDF files (which will print out a copy that looks just like the original). PDF files for cases published before October 1, 2001, have been removed from the server to make rom for more recent cases. If your computer is not able to read PDF documents, you may want to download the free Acrobat Reader.

Chronological Lists of Opinions

Recent Opinions

Court and Docket No. Name of Case Date Signed
2009 ME 107Merrill A. Efstathiou v. Dennis A. Efstathiou (PDF)10/27/2009
2009 ME 108Maine School Administrative District No. 27 v. Maine Public Employees Retirement System (PDF)11/05/2009
2009 ME 109Phillip Richardson v. Winthrop School Department (PDF)11/12/2009
2009 ME 110State of Maine v. Charles E. Bromiley IV (PDF)11/19/2009
2009 ME 111Jennie Clark v. Charles P. Heald (PDF)11/19/2009
2009 ME 112Frank D. Fournier v. Department of Corrections (PDF)11/19/2009
January 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 1 Lyle P. Merrifield v. Carole S. Hadlock 1/8/09
2009 ME 2 Monika G. Harmon v. Thomas E. Harmon 1/13/09
2009 ME 3 State of Maine v. Eugene Downs 1/13/09
2009 ME 4 Jean Hill, Individually and as Personal Representative of The Estate of Kenneth Hill v. Eddie S. Kwan et al. 1/13/09
2009 ME 5 Maine Health Care Association Workers' Compensation Fund v. Superintendent of Insurance et al. 1/13/09
2009 ME 6 State of Maine v. Dayle Lynn Johnson 1/13/09
2009 ME 7 State of Maine v. Tina Bickart 1/20/09
2009 ME 8 Stewart Title Guaranty Company v. State Tax Assessor 1/20/09
February 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 9 William Gaeth v. Daniel B. Deacon 2/3/09
2009 ME 10 In re Jacob C. 2/3/09
2009 ME 11 Department of Health and Human Services v. Vincent S. Pelletier 2/5/09
2009 ME 12 State of Maine v. Joseph J. DiPietro 2/5/09
2009 ME 13 John E. Skibinski v. Kay F. Skibinski 2/10/09
2009 ME 14 State of Maine v. Aimee E. King 2/10/09
2009 ME 15 Department of Health and Human Services v. Scott B. Maybee 2/10/09
2009 ME 16 Colby E. Ewing v. Maine District Court et al. 2/17/09
2009 ME 17 Estate of George L . Fournier 2/24/09
2009 ME 18 In re Robert S. et al. 2/26/09
March 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 19 Unifund CCR Partners v. Judy G. Demers 3/3/09
2009 ME 20 Craig Ayotte v. Belinda Ayotte 3/5/09
2009 ME 21 Estate of Clarence Dore v. Elizabeth Dore 3/10/09
2009 ME 22 State of Maine v. Timothy D. Rickett 3/10/09
2009 ME 23 State of Maine v. Robert D. Filion 3/10/09
2009 ME 24 Donald J. Beauchene v. Department of Health and Human Services 3/10/09
2009 ME 25 Glen A. Fournier et al. v. Charles H. Elliiott III et al. 3/10/09
2009 ME 26 In re Destiny T. et al. 3/10/09
2009 ME 27 Kathleen Kelley v. Maine Public Employees Retirement System 3/12/09
2009 ME 28 Debra L. (Sidney) Pratt v. Dean J. Sidney 3/17/09
2009 ME 29 Windham Land Trust et al. v. Russell I. Jeffords et al. 3/19/09
2009 ME 30 Nestle Waters North America, Inc. v. Town of Fryeburg et al. 3/19/09
2009 ME 31 Amy Melissa Hayes v. James R. Hayes 3/24/09
2009 ME 32 State of Maine v. Kathy L. Knight 3/24/09
2009 ME 33 State of Maine v. Dale Richard Weeks 3/24/09
April 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 34 Estate of Jessica Banks v. John Banks 4/7/09
2009 ME 35 Larry Jensen v. S.D. Warren Co. et al. 4/7/09
2009 ME 36 Brian Van Dam et al. v. Olive Spickler et al. 4/7/09
2009 ME 37 Helen Muther et al. v. Broad Cove Shore Association et al. 4/7/09
2009 ME 38 State of Maine v. Rodney Tucker 4/14/09
2009 ME 39 State of Maine v. John McDonough 4/16/09
2009 ME 40 Department of Corrections v. Public Utilities Commission 4/21/09
2009 ME 41 State of Maine v. Darrell J. Thurston 4/23/09
2009 ME 42 John L. Jorgensen et al. v. Department of Transportation 4/28/09
2009 ME 43 Frank Connolly et al. v. Maine Central Railroad Co. 4/30/09
2009 ME 44 State of Maine v. Michael Hutchinson 4/30/09
2009 ME 45 Lynn Gierie et al. v. Mercy Hospital 4/30/09
2009 ME 46 Brian Addy et al. v. Jenkins, Inc. 4/30/09
May 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 47 Linda Watt v. Unifirst Corporation 5/5/09
2009 ME 48 Town of Porter v. Clarence G. Blevens et al. 5/12/09
2009 ME 49 Carla Catlett v. David Catlett 5/12/09
2009 ME 50 Raymond Lavoie v. Re-Harvest, Inc.., et al. 5/12/09
2009 ME 51 Paul Dragomir v. Spring Harbor Hospital et al. 5/14/09
2009 ME 52 John T. Cyr & Sons, Inc. v. State Tax Assessor 5/14/09
2009 ME 53 Amanda Sue Wilcox et al. v. City of Portland 5/14/09
2009 ME 54 Lori A. Young v. Donald E. Young 5/28/09
June 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 55 Platz Associates v. Martin Finley et al. 6/2/09
2009 ME 56 Paul L. Nergaard et al. v. Town of Westport Island 6/2/09
2009 ME 57 Kelly Jo Cookson v. Brewer School Department et al. 6/2/09
2009 ME 58 State of Maine v. John Auclair 6/9/09
2009 ME 59 In re Trever I. 6/11/09
2009 ME 60 Robert W. Britton et al. v. Department of Conservation et al.

Issued 6/18/09

Revised 7/9/09

2009 ME 61 State of Maine v. Gina Bruzzese 6/18/09
2009 ME 62 Bar Harbor Bank & Trust v. The Woods at Moody, LLC, et al. 6/23/09
2009 ME 63 State of Maine v. David Vaughan 6/23/09
July 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 64 Lakeside at Pleasant Mountain Condominium Association v. Town of Bridgton et al. 7/7/09
2009 ME 65 Carol Beaudoin v. Tambrands, Inc. 7/7/09
2009 ME 66 Alberta Wister v. Town of Mount Desert et al. 7/7/09
2009 ME 67 William Picher v. The Roman Catholic Bishop of Portland et al. 7/7/09
2009 ME 60 Robert W. Britton et al. v. Department of Conservation et al.

Issued 6/18/09

Revised 7/9/09

2009 ME 68 Jason Labonte et al. v. Jeffrey Thurlow et al. 7/9/09
2009 ME 69 John McKinnon et al. v. Honeywell International, Inc. 7/16/09
2009 ME 70 Adoption of Hali D. 7/16/09
2009 ME 71 Fiber Materials, Inc. v. Maurice Subilia et al. 7/16/09
2009 ME 72 State of Maine v. Rory C. Holland 7/21/09
2009 ME 73 Betsy A. Wandishin v. Edward M. Wandishin Jr. 7/21/09
2009 ME 74 Guardianship of Jeremiah T. 7/23/09
2009 ME 75 Department of Health and Human Services v. Willia Tardif 7/23/09
2009 ME 76 Adoption of Patricia S. 7/23/09
2009 ME 77 Terry P. Wyman v. Town of Phippsburg et al. 7/28/09
2009 ME 78 State of Maine v. Donald K. Christen 7/28/09
2009 ME 79 Alan D. Knowlton v. Attorney General et al. 7/28/09
2009 ME 80 Todd S. Holbrook v. Lisa J. Holbrook 7/30/09
August 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 81 In re Penelope W. 8/4/09
2009 ME 82 Lorraine Davis et al. v. SBA Towers II, LLC f/k/a National Grid Communications, Inc. 8/6/09
2009 ME 83 Richard E. Hamilton Jr. v. Kellie M. Hamilton et al. 8/6/09
2009 ME 84 Downeast Mortgage Corporation v. Carol Ann Cutler 8/6/09
2009 ME 85 In re Baby Duncan 8/6/09
2009 ME 86 Paul F. Garland et al. v. Peter R. Roy et al. 8/6/09
2009 ME 87 State of Maine v. Brent L. McKeen 8/11/09
2009 ME 88 Jane Doe v. Jennifer Graham et al. 8/13/09
2009 ME 89 Anthony Uliano et al. v. Board of Environmental Protection 8/13/09
2009 ME 90 State of Maine v. Jay R. McLaughlin 8/18/09
2009 ME 91 State of Maine v. Sean T. Connor 8/18/09
2009 ME 92 St. Mary's Regional Medical Center v. Bath Iron Works 8/18/09
2009 ME 93 In re Richard E. and In re Anthony P. 8/20/09
2009 ME 94 State of Maine v. Michael Labbe 8/27/09
September 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 95 In re Cody T. 9/1/09
2009 ME 96 Igor Malenko v. Lori Handrahan 9/1/09
2009 ME 97 Guardianship of Anthony J. 9/3/09
2009 ME 98 The Portland Company v. The City of Portland 9/3/09
2009 ME 99 F. James Whalen v. Down East Community Hospital 9/15/09
2009 ME 100 Sharon McPhee v. Maine State Retirement System, Joanne McPhee, Intervenor 9/22/09
2009 ME 101 Blue Star Corporation v. CKF Properties, LLC, et al. 9/24/09
October 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 102 State of Maine v. Ashton Moores 10/6/09
2009 ME 103 State of Maine v. Frederick C. Johnson 10/8/09
2009 ME 104 In re Motion to Quash Bar Counsel Subpoena 10/27/09
2009 ME 105 Donald J. Cassidy et al. v. Wendy M. Cassidy et al. 10/27/09
2009 ME 106 State of Maine v. Corey L. Townsend 10/27/09
2009 ME 107 Merrill A. Efstathiou v. Dennis A. Efstathiou 10/27/09
November 2009
Opinion # Case Date
2009 ME 108 Maine School Administrative District No. 27 v. Maine Public Employees Retirement System November 5, 2009
2009 ME 109 Phillip Richardson v. Winthrop School Department November 12, 2009
2009 ME 110 State of Maine v. Charles E. Bromiley IV November 19, 2009
2009 ME 111 Jennie Clark v. Charles P. Heald November 19, 2009
2009 ME 112 Frank D. Fournier v. Department of Corrections November 19, 2009

 

New opinions will be added Tuesdays and Thursdays. They are usually posted around 11:00 a.m.

Looking for cases older than 1997? (Please note that opinions prior to October 2001, no longer have pdf versions available. They have been deleted to make room on the server for the newer opinions.) Effective October 20, 2006, all new opinions are being loaded on this website in pdf format only. Here's some help.

Recent Memoranda of Decision

Previous Month
Current Month

Advisory Opinions and other original proceedings

Maine Rules of Appellate Procedure

Bar Discipline Decisions

For the newest Administrative Orders, Rules Amendments and Judicial Branch announcements, see the News & Announcements page.

If you have comments or suggestions concerning this page, please contact the page administrator by e-mail, or mail to Judicial Branch, Page Administrator, P O Box 368, Portland ME 04112-0368.